How accurate are pet food labels? A label vs laboratory comparison explained
One study tested 18 insect-based dog foods sold in South Korea and found lab results differed from the pack in 7. Here is what it shows, how it compares with other studies, and how brands can check their own labels.
- In 18 insect-based dog foods sold in South Korea, measured values differed from the package in 7, although all met AAFCO proximate guidelines.
- The one reported example was a food labelled at 13% crude fat that measured 10.17%.
- Minerals were the weak point: calcium, phosphorus, zinc, iron and copper fell short in several foods, and six had a Ca:P ratio outside 1:1 to 2:1.
- AAFCO advises at least two analyses per variety and setting guarantees from the mean minus or plus two standard deviations, not from one batch.

Pet food label accuracy is how closely laboratory results match the guaranteed analysis on the pack. In one study of 18 insect-based dog foods sold in South Korea, all 18 met AAFCO proximate guidelines, but measured values differed from the package in 7 1. One food labelled at 13% crude fat measured 10.17% 2. Labels are usually close on the headline numbers, but not always, and a single bag cannot show how a brand’s batches vary.
01What “accurate” means on a pet food label
This page explains one study that put the declared panel next to laboratory results, sets it beside two others and shows how a brand can check its own label.
In the US, the guaranteed analysis is a set of limits, not measured averages. Crude protein and crude fat are minimums; crude fibre and moisture are maximums. “Crude” names the analytical method, not ingredient quality: crude protein is nitrogen multiplied by 6.25 3. A label is therefore accurate when a batch stays on the correct side of each guarantee, and AAFCO notes that failing a guarantee may lead to enforcement action 4. For what each line means, see guaranteed analysis explained.
02The study at a glance
| Citation | Ryu MO, Lee KH, Ha HM, Kim HR, Ahn WS, Kim SH, Seo KW. Am J Vet Res 2025;86(1):ajvr.24.08.0243 1 |
|---|---|
| Question | Do commercial insect-based dog foods match their labels and AAFCO guidelines? |
| Sample | 18 insect-based dog foods on the South Korean market, made with black soldier fly larvae (BSFL) or mealworm, both Korean-made and imported 12 |
| Analyses | Proximate composition, amino acids, fatty acids and minerals |
| Compared with | Package values and AAFCO dog food guidelines |
| Authors | Seoul National University 2; funding not stated in the sources we read |
Table 1. Study design, from the abstract and a trade press report 12. We could not access the full text, so sampling and laboratory methods are not described here.
03What the researchers found
- Proximate guidelines were met. All 18 foods met AAFCO guidelines for the proximate nutrients, and all met adult maintenance amino acid requirements 12.
- Labels and lab results differed in 7 of 18 foods (39%). The one example reported was a food labelled at 13% crude fat that measured 10.17%, about 22% below the declared minimum 2.
- Minerals were the weak point. Magnesium met guidelines in every food, but calcium, phosphorus, zinc, iron and copper fell short in several samples 1. Shortfalls were more common in Korean-made foods. Two foods had a calcium to phosphorus ratio below 1:1 and four above 2:1, with one at 2.95:1 2.
- Fatty acids and growth nutrients. Two foods exceeded the recommended maximum omega-6 to omega-3 ratio, and BSFL foods had more lauric and myristic acid than mealworm foods 1. Three foods fell short of growth and reproduction levels for EPA plus DHA, and three all-life-stage foods for threonine 2.
The authors called for stricter regulation, better enforcement of existing guidelines and more accurate labelling 1. For background on these ingredients, see insect and cultivated proteins.
Measured results, one analysis set per product. Counts of 18, 7 and 2 are from the abstract 1; 6 and 3 from a trade press summary of the paper 2. Axis 0–18 foods.
View data table
| Finding | Foods (of 18) |
|---|---|
| Met AAFCO proximate guidelines | 18 |
| Measured values differed from package | 7 |
| Ca:P ratio outside 1:1 to 2:1 (2 below, 4 above) | 6 |
| EPA + DHA below growth and reproduction level | 3 |
| Omega-6:omega-3 ratio above maximum | 2 |
04How it compares with other studies
| Study | Foods analysed | Compared with | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ryu 2025 | 18 insect-based dog foods, South Korea | Package values and AAFCO | Package and lab differed in 7; all met proximate guidelines 1 |
| Brociek 2025 | 31 dry dog foods, UK (19 meat-based, 6 veterinary renal, 6 plant-based) | Label protein and FEDIAF | Measured protein “corresponded well” with the label; no food met every guideline; 55% met all amino acid and 16% all mineral minimums 5 |
| German 2025 | 61 adult and senior diets, 25 brands, bought in Colorado, US | AAFCO adult maintenance only | 11 of 61 (18%) missed at least one requirement, all for calcium, phosphorus, potassium or Ca:P 6 |
Table 2. Three analytical studies of commercial dog foods. Benchmarks differ, so the rows are not directly comparable. Brociek was funded by a UK research council (BBSRC) studentship; German by a university companion animal centre grant.
Across the three studies, minerals and their ratios are where foods most often fall short; where protein was checked against the label, it was usually close. Brociek gave no statistic for the protein match, and German did not compare with labels.
05Limits, and what the study does not show
- We read the abstract and press coverage, not the full paper, so we cannot say how large the other six label gaps were or in which direction.
- We could not confirm how many samples of each product were analysed. A result from one lot shows direction, not a brand’s batch spread 4.
- Eighteen products from one market, in a newer category, is a small sample.
- The study does not show harm to dogs. No feeding trial was run, and the authors called for one 2.
06Batch variation and setting guarantees
AAFCO’s guidance names three causes of batch variation: ingredient composition, mixing rates and the water lost during cooking. It recommends at least two analyses of each variety to start, then setting guarantees from the mean and standard deviation, since the mean ± 2 SD covers about 95% of batches. The pages we read give no numeric analytical tolerance 4.
| Step | Crude protein |
|---|---|
| Four batches analysed | 25.0%, 26.0%, 25.2%, 23.0% |
| Mean and standard deviation | 24.8%; 1.28 |
| Mean − 2 SD | 22.25% |
| Guarantee printed | Crude protein, min 22% |
Table 3. AAFCO worked example 4; we re-ran the arithmetic using the sample SD. Printing 25% from the first batch alone would have failed on batch four.
AAFCO’s Pet Food Label Modernization (PFLM) moves these lines into a Pet Nutrition Facts box. The guarantees keep their direction, as protein (min), fat (min), moisture (max) and dietary fibre (max), which replaces crude fibre 7. See AAFCO label modernization for the changes.
07How brands verify their own labels
Label verification checklist
- Analyse at least two production batches of each variety before artwork is final 4.
- Set each guarantee from the batch spread, not the best result.
- Run calcium, phosphorus and the main trace minerals, not only the four guarantees, because that is where foods most often miss.
- Use near-infrared (NIR) screening for moisture, protein and fat only; in 106 pet foods it predicted crude fibre, ash, calcium and phosphorus poorly 8.
- Re-test after any supplier, recipe or process change.
Our guide to proximate analysis of pet food covers the methods, and the same label-versus-measured question for energy is graded in calories in dog food.
A small but useful study: every food met AAFCO’s proximate guidelines, yet 7 of 18 did not match their own packs, and minerals were the weak point. Read it as a prompt to test several batches and minerals, not as proof that labels are generally wrong.
08For brands and formulators
09Questions brands ask
Are pet food labels accurate?
Usually close on protein and fat, less reliably beyond them. In one study of 18 insect-based dog foods, all met AAFCO proximate guidelines but measured values differed from the package in 7, and minerals were the most common shortfall.
How is a pet food label checked against laboratory results?
Representative samples are homogenised and analysed, usually by proximate analysis plus minerals, and each result is compared with the direction of its guarantee: protein and fat should be at or above the minimum, fibre and moisture at or below the maximum.
Why do label and lab values differ?
AAFCO names ingredient variation, mixing rates and water lost during cooking as causes of batch-to-batch variation. Method assumptions also matter: crude protein is nitrogen × 6.25, which can overestimate plant protein.
What tolerance is allowed on a pet food label?
The AAFCO pages we read give no numeric analytical tolerance. Guarantees are minimums or maximums, and AAFCO advises setting them about two standard deviations beyond the batch mean so roughly 95% of batches comply.
How many batches should a brand test before printing a guaranteed analysis?
AAFCO suggests at least two analyses of each variety to start, with more batches giving a better estimate of variation. Re-test after any recipe, supplier or process change.
Read the label verification guides in order
- Guaranteed analysis explained · what each line means
- Crude fibre vs dietary fibre · why the label figure reads low
- How accurate are pet food labels? · you are here
- Calories in dog food · label vs measured energy, graded
- Proximate analysis of pet food · methods, tolerances and turnaround
- Worked case study · a dog treat label checked across four batches
- Nutritional analysis · how we run it for your product
Sources
- Ryu MO, Lee KH, Ha HM, Kim HR, Ahn WS, Kim SH, Seo KW (2025). Proximate analysis and profiles of amino acids, fatty acids, and minerals in insect-based foods for dogs. American Journal of Veterinary Research 86(1):ajvr.24.08.0243. Source ↗
- Wall T (2025). Some insect-based pet foods imbalanced, low in certain nutrients. Petfood Industry, 29 May 2025. Source ↗
- Association of American Feed Control Officials. Reading labels: understanding pet food. AAFCO website, accessed November 2026. Source ↗
- Association of American Feed Control Officials. Nutritional labeling (start-up resources: calculating the guaranteed analysis). AAFCO website, accessed November 2026. Source ↗
- Brociek RA, Li D, Broughton R, Gardner DS (2025). Nutritional analysis of commercially available, complete plant- and meat-based dry dog foods in the UK. PLOS ONE 20(9):e0328506. Source ↗
- German K, Melgoza C, Torres-Henderson C (2025). Exploratory analysis of nutrient composition of adult and senior dog diets. Frontiers in Veterinary Science 12:1717409. Source ↗
- Association of American Feed Control Officials (2023). Pet Food Label Modernization: Pet Nutrition Facts (V1, 31 July 2023). Source ↗
- Fan Y, Liao J, Zhou Q, et al. (2024). Rapid prediction of the chemical composition of pet food using a benchtop and handheld near-infrared spectrometer. Spectrochimica Acta Part A: Molecular and Biomolecular Spectroscopy 323:124916. Source ↗
Evidence reviewed by the Guires Pet Nutrition Lab scientific team. This article is general information for product developers and is not legal or veterinary advice.
How to cite this article
Choose your referencing style, then copy. Check your university’s, journal’s or regulator’s guide for local variations.
Mehta, P. (2026, November 13). How accurate are pet food labels? A label vs laboratory comparison explained. Guires Pet Nutrition Lab Insights. https://www.petnutritionlab.com/insights/pet-food-label-accuracy-label-vs-laboratory-study
Mehta, Priya. “How accurate are pet food labels? A label vs laboratory comparison explained.” Guires Pet Nutrition Lab Insights, 13 Nov. 2026, www.petnutritionlab.com/insights/pet-food-label-accuracy-label-vs-laboratory-study. Accessed [date].
Mehta, P. (2026) How accurate are pet food labels? A label vs laboratory comparison explained. Available at: https://www.petnutritionlab.com/insights/pet-food-label-accuracy-label-vs-laboratory-study (Accessed: [date accessed]).
Mehta, Priya. “How accurate are pet food labels? A label vs laboratory comparison explained.” Guires Pet Nutrition Lab Insights. November 13, 2026. https://www.petnutritionlab.com/insights/pet-food-label-accuracy-label-vs-laboratory-study.
Priya Mehta, ‘How accurate are pet food labels? A label vs laboratory comparison explained’, Guires Pet Nutrition Lab Insights, 13 November 2026, <https://www.petnutritionlab.com/insights/pet-food-label-accuracy-label-vs-laboratory-study>, accessed [date accessed].
Mehta P. How accurate are pet food labels? A label vs laboratory comparison explained [Internet]. Guires Pet Nutrition Lab Insights; 2026 Nov 13 [cited [date]]. Available from: https://www.petnutritionlab.com/insights/pet-food-label-accuracy-label-vs-laboratory-study
P. Mehta, “How accurate are pet food labels? A label vs laboratory comparison explained,” Guires Pet Nutrition Lab Insights, Nov. 13, 2026. [Online]. Available: https://www.petnutritionlab.com/insights/pet-food-label-accuracy-label-vs-laboratory-study
@misc{guirespnl2026petfoodlabelaccuracylabelvslaboratorystudy,
author = {Mehta, Priya},
title = {{How accurate are pet food labels? A label vs laboratory comparison explained}},
year = {2026},
month = oct,
howpublished = {\url{https://www.petnutritionlab.com/insights/pet-food-label-accuracy-label-vs-laboratory-study}},
note = {Guires Pet Nutrition Lab Insights}
}
This article summarises published evidence for product developers. Cite the original sources above for specific findings, and do not reproduce this article as your own work.
Is your label backed by data?
Send us your label and samples. We compare declared and measured values across batches and flag every gap before launch.