Worked Example · Label Verification · Dog Treats

Case study: verifying a soft dog chew’s guaranteed analysis and calorie statement before launch

What happens if a treat label is printed from one pilot batch? This worked example takes a hypothetical soft dog chew for the US market through four batch analyses, AAFCO’s guarantee-setting method and a calculated calorie statement in kcal per kg and per chew. It is an illustrative example by Guires PNL scientists. There is no client, no client data and no testimonial: the batch numbers are AAFCO’s own published example.

Illustrative worked example, no client · By Priya Mehta, Guires PNL scientific team · Published 13 Nov 2026 · Last checked 13 Nov 2026

ProjectWorked exampleNo client: AAFCO’s published batch data
ProductSoft dog chewTreat, US market, 10 g chew (assumed)
ServiceNutritional analysisGuarantees and calorie statement
Result3 of 4Batches that would miss a batch-one label
01 · The Brief

What the brief asked for.

  • A soft dog chew sold as a treat in the US, with “treat” on the principal display panel, so no nutritional adequacy statement is needed 2.
  • A guaranteed analysis with the four required lines, minimum crude protein and crude fat and maximum crude fibre and moisture, plus an optional ash maximum after moisture 23.
  • A calorie content statement in kcal of metabolisable energy per kg as fed and per chew 5.
  • Federal label basics under 21 CFR 501: name of the food, ingredients in descending order by weight, net quantity and the manufacturer’s name and address 4.
Soft dog chews being weighed for proximate analysis and a per-treat calorie calculation
Illustrative image. This worked example is a method, not a product on sale.

Worked example prepared by Priya Mehta, Guires PNL scientific team. The batch values are AAFCO’s published example, not measured client data.

At a glance

Format
Soft dog chew, 10 g per chew (assumed)
Market
United States: FDA (21 CFR 501) and state rules based on AAFCO model regulations
Batch data
AAFCO’s four-batch worked example 1
Data status
Illustrative; no client, no testimonial
4Batches analysed (AAFCO advises at least 2)
3 of 4Batches that miss a batch-one label
0 of 4Batches that miss the four-batch guarantees
3,688Mean kcal/kg as fed, calculated
36.9Mean kcal per 10 g chew, calculated
0Client results shown

The AAFCO batches run at 7.8–9.1% moisture, which is a dry product. A real soft chew is likely to carry more water, which would lower every as-fed figure; the method is the same.

02 · Constraints

What had to hold.

01

Guarantees are limits

Protein and fat are guaranteed as minimums, fibre, moisture and ash as maximums. Every batch on sale has to meet them, not just the average, as our guaranteed analysis guide explains.

02

One result hides the spread

AAFCO warns that a single analytical value gives no indication of batch-to-batch variation, and that a product can fail when a feed control official tests a sample in a state lab 1.

03

Calories are an average

The calorie statement is declared as an average of multiple proximate analyses, not as a minimum or maximum 3, and carries “(calculated)” or “(fed)” after its heading 5.

04

Chews vary in practice

AAFCO notes that many chews on the market carry no calorie statement or guaranteed analysis at all 6. This brief includes both, so the numbers have to stand up.

03 · What We Did

Label verification in five steps.

  1. Sample four batches

    AAFCO advises at least two analyses of each variety to start 1. We used four, matching its example, each from a separate production batch.

  2. Run the proximate panel

    Each batch gets crude protein, crude fat, crude fibre, moisture and ash, reported as fed. The methods are set out in our proximate analysis guide.

  3. Convert to dry matter

    Dry matter = 100 − moisture. Comparing batches on a dry-matter basis shows whether a low as-fed value is a real recipe shift or just extra water.

  4. Set the guarantees

    For each line, take the mean and standard deviation, then set the guarantee beyond the mean ± 2 SD. For protein, 24.8 − 2 × 1.28 = 22.25, so the minimum guarantee is 22% 1.

  5. Calculate the calories

    Nitrogen-free extract (NFE) = 100 − (protein + fat + fibre + moisture + ash). Energy uses the modified Atwater formula in AAFCO Regulation PF9: kcal/kg = 10 × (3.5 × protein + 8.5 × fat + 3.5 × NFE) 5. Per chew = kcal/kg × 0.010 kg.

Figure 1Moisture by batch against two labelsMoisture as fed, % (batch-one label 7.8% max; four-batch guarantee 10% max)
Batch 1
7.8
Batch 2
8.9
Batch 3
8.1
Batch 4
9.1

Highlighted bars exceed the 7.8% maximum a batch-one label would print; all four are inside the 10% maximum set by AAFCO’s method. Values from AAFCO’s published example 1, not a client product. Axis 0–12%.

View data table
BatchMoisture (%)Batch-one label (≤7.8%)Four-batch guarantee (≤10%)
17.8PassPass
28.9MissPass
38.1MissPass
49.1MissPass
04 · Results

What the four batches showed.

Protein ran from 23% to 26% as fed and moisture from 7.8% to 9.1%. On a dry-matter basis, batch 4 is still the lowest in protein (25.3% against 27.1–28.5% for the others), so its low as-fed value is a real shift, not dilution by water. Calculated energy ranged from 3,625 to 3,733 kcal/kg, −1.7% to +1.2% around the mean of 3,688 kcal/kg.

Table 1. Batch results and calculated energy

BatchProtein %Fat %Fibre %Moisture %Ash %NFE %Protein % DMkcal/kgkcal per 10 g chew
125.015.04.57.83.244.527.13,70837.1
226.014.33.28.93.044.628.53,68736.9
325.213.04.08.12.946.827.43,62536.3
423.016.03.89.13.344.825.33,73337.3
Mean24.814.583.888.483.1045.1827.13,68836.9

Proximate values as fed from AAFCO’s worked example 1. NFE, dry-matter protein, energy and per-chew values are our calculations; the 10 g chew weight is an assumption. Illustrative, not a soft chew or a client product.

Table 2. Batch-one label versus four-batch guarantees

LineBatch-one labelBatches that miss itMean ± 2 SDAAFCO-method guaranteeBatches that miss it
Crude protein (min)25Batch 4 (23)22.2522None
Crude fat (min)15Batches 2 (14.3) and 3 (13)12.0512None
Crude fibre (max)4.5None4.955None
Moisture (max)7.8Batches 2, 3 and 49.7210None
Ash (max)3.2Batch 4 (3.3)3.473.5None

Guarantees and mean ± 2 SD values from AAFCO 1; miss counts are our comparison of each batch with each label. Batches 2, 3 and 4 each miss at least one batch-one line.

Figure 2Calculated calories per chew by batchkcal ME per 10 g chew, modified Atwater, as fed
Batch 1
37.1
Batch 2
36.9
Batch 3
36.3
Batch 4
37.3
Mean (declared)
36.9

Calculated, not measured: kcal/kg = 10 × (3.5 × protein + 8.5 × fat + 3.5 × NFE) 5, from AAFCO’s batch data, with an assumed 10 g chew. Axis 0–40 kcal.

View data table
Batchkcal/kgkcal per 10 g chew
13,70837.1
23,68736.9
33,62536.3
43,73337.3
Mean3,68836.9

The calculated statement reads “Calorie Content (calculated): 3,688 kcal ME/kg; 36.9 kcal ME per chew”. How close is a calculated figure to the energy a dog actually gets? In 224 dry extruded dog foods tested in Brazil, the modified Atwater factors gave values on average about 8.6% below in vivo metabolisable energy 7. No soft chew was studied, so treat that as direction only; our label vs measured energy review grades the wider evidence. Label gaps are not hypothetical either: in 18 insect-based dog foods, declared and measured values differed in 7, mostly on crude protein or crude fat 8.

05 · Lessons

What this means for treat brands.

01

Test several batches

A label printed from batch one would have been missed by three of the next four batches in this example. Two analyses is AAFCO’s floor; four gives a usable standard deviation 1.

02

Set limits from the spread

Guarantees placed beyond the mean ± 2 SD covered all four batches. Use the spread, not the best batch.

03

Declare calories as the mean

Declare the average from the same data, state “(calculated)”, and recalculate when fat or moisture moves 35.

04

Plan for label changes

AAFCO’s modernised model regulations replace the crude fibre guarantee with dietary fibre and add a non-fibre carbohydrate line 9. Check which version your target states have adopted before artwork is final.

Label verification cluster · Part 6 of 7

Read the label verification guides in order

  1. Guaranteed analysis explained · what each line means and how it is tested
  2. Crude fibre vs dietary fibre · what the fibre line measures
  3. How accurate are pet food labels? · a label vs laboratory comparison
  4. Calories in dog food · label vs measured energy
  5. Proximate analysis of pet food · methods, tolerances and turnaround
  6. Worked case study · you are here
  7. Nutritional analysis · how we run it for your product

References

  1. Association of American Feed Control Officials. Nutritional labeling: how do I calculate the guaranteed analysis in my pet treats? AAFCO startup resources (web page, accessed 13 Nov 2026). Source ↗
  2. Association of American Feed Control Officials. Reading labels. AAFCO consumer resources (web page, accessed 13 Nov 2026). Source ↗
  3. Association of American Feed Control Officials. Labeling & labeling requirements. AAFCO startup resources (web page, accessed 13 Nov 2026). Source ↗
  4. US Food and Drug Administration. How do I start an animal food business? (content current as of 13 Feb 2024). Label requirements under 21 CFR part 501. Source ↗
  5. Texas Administrative Code, Title 4, §63.9. Statement of caloric content (state adoption of AAFCO Model Regulation PF9). Source ↗
  6. Association of American Feed Control Officials. Treats and chews. AAFCO consumer resources (web page, accessed 13 Nov 2026). Source ↗
  7. Marchi PH, Amaral AR, Príncipe LA, Risolia LW, Rentas MF, Fasolai AB, et al. (2025). Accuracy of predictive equations for metabolizable energy compared to energy content of foods for dogs and cats estimated by in vivo methods in Brazil. Animals 15(10):1477. No external funding. Source ↗
  8. Ryu MO, Lee KH, Ha HM, Kim HR, Ahn WS, Kim SH, Seo KW (2025). Proximate analysis and profiles of amino acids, fatty acids, and minerals in insect-based foods for dogs. American Journal of Veterinary Research 86(1):ajvr.24.08.0243. Source ↗
  9. Association of American Feed Control Officials. Model regulations for pet food and specialty pet food under the Model Bill (Pet Food Label Modernization revision), PF4. Source ↗

Worked example: all batch values are AAFCO’s published four-batch example, not measured client data, and there is no client or testimonial. Nitrogen-free extract, dry-matter values, energy, per-chew calories and miss counts are Guires PNL calculations under the stated assumptions. US rules only; requirements differ by state and in other markets. Final responsibility for product compliance rests with the brand owner placing the product on the market.

Launching a treat with a guaranteed analysis on the pack?

Send us the product format, the batches you have and your target market. A scientist will reply with a sampling plan, the panel we would run and how the guarantees and calorie statement would be set.

FEDIAFAAFCO

Every Guires PNL product is formulated to comply with the FEDIAF Nutritional Guidelines and the AAFCO Dog and Cat Food Nutrient Profiles. Neither body issues certificates to manufacturers, so compliance is verified independently against their published standards — and every product comes with a complete documentation package for regulatory submissions in the EU, US, Australia and Asian markets.

How we verify compliance →
Request a quote Call us WhatsApp Email us