Proximate analysis of pet food: methods, tolerances and turnaround
Five measurements and one subtraction sit behind the panel on every bag. Knowing how each is run, and how much variation regulators allow, tells you what a result can and cannot prove.
- A proximate panel measures moisture, crude protein, crude fat, crude fibre and ash, and carbohydrate (NFE) is calculated by difference.
- Crude protein is nitrogen × 6.25, measured by Kjeldahl (AOAC 2001.11) or combustion (AOAC 990.03), and the factor can overstate plant protein.
- AAFCO’s analytical variations allow, for example, (20/x + 2)% of the guarantee for protein and 10% for fat before a sample is judged short.
- AAFCO advises setting guarantees from several batches, using the mean plus or minus two standard deviations.

Proximate analysis of pet food measures moisture, crude protein, crude fat, crude fibre and ash on the finished product 1. Carbohydrate (nitrogen-free extract) is then calculated by difference. The results set and check the guaranteed analysis and can feed the calorie statement. In the US, regulators judge a result against the guarantee using AAFCO’s analytical variations, which allow about 3% of a 22% protein guarantee and 10–12% for fat and moisture.
01What a proximate panel measures
Every US pet food label must guarantee minimum crude protein and crude fat and maximum crude fibre and moisture 2. A proximate panel tests those four on the finished product and adds ash, which is optional on the label but normally appears in the report. Results are typically reported as fed 1. “Crude” refers to the analytical method, not the quality of the nutrient 3. Our guaranteed analysis guide explains each label line; this page covers how the numbers are produced and judged.
02The methods behind each line
Each line is a separate test on a ground, mixed subsample. Crude protein is nitrogen multiplied by 6.25 2, measured by Kjeldahl digestion or by combustion (Dumas) 4. Table 1 lists AOAC Official Methods named for feed and pet food.
| Line | What is measured | AOAC methods | Watch for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Moisture | Loss on drying | 930.15 (135 °C, 2 h); 934.01 (vacuum oven, 95–100 °C) 4 | Sets the basis for every dry matter conversion |
| Crude protein | Nitrogen × 6.25 | 2001.11 Kjeldahl, copper catalyst; 990.03 combustion 4 | The 6.25 factor can overstate plant protein 5 |
| Crude fat | Solvent extract, with or without acid hydrolysis | 920.39 ether extract 6; 954.02 acid hydrolysis 4 | The report should name which one was used |
| Crude fibre | Residue after acid and alkali digestion | 962.09 6; 978.10 (fritted glass crucible) 4 | Not the same as dietary fibre |
| Ash | Residue after burning | 942.05 6 | Optional on the label; must follow moisture if listed 2 |
Table 1. Proximate lines and AOAC Official Methods named for feed and pet food. Method numbers as listed in the cited AAFCO-hosted and extension sources.
A UK study of 31 dry dog foods measured nitrogen with a combustion analyser and also summed individual amino acids, because the 6.25 factor can overestimate vegetable protein 5. Crude protein says nothing about protein quality or processing damage. For that, see our protein and active analysis work.
03Carbohydrate by difference and the calorie figure
Nitrogen-free extract (NFE) is not measured. AAFCO defines it as 100 minus crude protein, crude fat, crude fibre, moisture and ash. Calculated metabolisable energy then uses modified Atwater factors: [(3.5 × protein) + (8.5 × fat) + (3.5 × NFE)] × 10, in kcal/kg 7. The calorie statement is declared as an average of several proximate analyses, not as a minimum or maximum 3.
Worked example (our illustrative figures): moisture 10%, protein 26%, fat 15%, fibre 4% and ash 7% give NFE of 38% and 3,515 kcal/kg. If ash reads one point high, NFE falls to 37% and energy to 3,480 kcal/kg. If fat reads one point low, energy falls to 3,465 kcal/kg. Every measured error lands in the carbohydrate and calorie figures. Our review of label vs measured calories shows how far these estimates can drift.
04Tolerances: AAFCO analytical variations
AAFCO publishes an Analytical Variations (AV) table in its Official Publication. Control officials use it to decide whether a sample that misses its guarantee is still acceptable, because sampling and analysis add variation of their own 6. The AV is a percentage of the guarantee (x): moisture 12%, crude protein (20/x + 2)%, crude fat 10%, crude fibre (30/x + 6)% and ash (45/x + 3)%, each within a stated concentration range 6. A Texas State Chemist presentation lists the same formulas as the current AVs 8. Check the current Official Publication before relying on them, and check your state: Kentucky, for example, publishes its own tolerance table 9.
Calculated by Guires PNL from the AAFCO AV formulas 6 for an illustrative dry dog food. Not measured data. Axis 0–15%.
View data table
| Guarantee | AV (% of guarantee) | AV (percentage points) | Limit |
|---|---|---|---|
| Crude protein 22% min | 2.9 | 0.64 | 21.36% |
| Ash 8% max | 8.6 | 0.69 | 8.69% |
| Crude fat 12% min | 10.0 | 1.20 | 10.80% |
| Moisture 10% max | 12.0 | 1.20 | 11.20% |
| Crude fibre 4% max | 13.5 | 0.54 | 4.54% |
Protein has the tightest allowance, so a protein guarantee set at the batch average is the line most likely to fail an official sample.
05Setting guarantees from batch data
AAFCO advises at least two analyses of each variety to start, and more batches for a better estimate of spread. Take the mean and standard deviation of each nutrient: the mean plus or minus two standard deviations covers about 95% of production 1. In AAFCO’s example, the first batch tested 25% protein, a later one 23%, and four batches averaged 24.8%. Mean minus two standard deviations was 22.25%, so the prudent minimum was 22% 1.
Set the guarantee from your own production spread. California’s guidance says a guarantee should not add extra margin for analytical or sampling variation 10; the AV is the regulator’s allowance, not yours.
06Turnaround and what to ask a lab
Turnaround depends on the laboratory, the panel and the queue, and we found no published benchmark. Typically the proximate panel is the quicker part of a quote: amino acid, mineral and vitamin work each need separate specialist methods and reference materials 5. Ask for working days in writing, per panel. If you are moving to the new Pet Nutrition Facts box, plan for dietary fibre, which replaces crude fibre, and a calculated carbohydrate maximum 12. See crude fibre vs dietary fibre.
Before you send samples
- Ask for the AOAC (or equivalent) method number for every line.
- Confirm the accreditation scope, for example ISO/IEC 17025, covers those methods and your matrix.
- Ask which reference or check samples the lab runs alongside yours.
- Specify the reporting basis: as fed, with dry matter on request.
- Send several production batches, not one pilot sample.
- Get turnaround and any rush option in writing.
A proximate result is only as useful as its method, its basis and the number of batches behind it. Set guarantees from production spread, know the AAFCO analytical variations a regulator will apply, and treat rapid screening as a check, not as evidence.
07Questions brands ask
What is proximate analysis of pet food?
It is a standard set of tests for moisture, crude protein, crude fat, crude fibre and ash on the finished product. Carbohydrate, as nitrogen-free extract, is calculated by difference rather than measured.
How is protein measured in pet food?
Nitrogen is measured, by Kjeldahl digestion or combustion, and multiplied by 6.25 to give crude protein. The factor can overstate protein from plant ingredients.
What tolerances apply to pet food guarantees in the US?
Control officials use the Analytical Variations table in the AAFCO Official Publication, for example (20/x + 2)% of the guarantee for crude protein and 12% for moisture. Some states publish their own tolerance tables, so check where you sell.
How long does pet food testing take?
It depends on the laboratory, the panel and the queue. A proximate panel is typically quicker than amino acid, mineral or vitamin work, so ask for working days per panel in writing.
How many samples do I need to set a guaranteed analysis?
AAFCO advises at least two analyses of each variety to start and more batches over time. Use the mean plus or minus two standard deviations to set minimums and maximums.
Read the label verification guides in order
- Guaranteed analysis explained · what each line means
- Crude fibre vs dietary fibre · why the label figure reads low
- How accurate are pet food labels? · one label vs lab study explained
- Calories in dog food · label vs measured energy, graded
- Proximate analysis of pet food · you are here
- Worked case study · a dog treat label checked across four batches
- Nutritional analysis · how we run it for your product
Sources
- Association of American Feed Control Officials. Nutritional labeling: how do I calculate the guaranteed analysis in my pet treats? AAFCO startup resources (web page), accessed November 2026. Source ↗
- Association of American Feed Control Officials. Reading labels: understanding pet food. AAFCO consumer resources (web page), accessed November 2026. Source ↗
- Association of American Feed Control Officials. Labeling & labeling requirements. AAFCO startup resources (web page), accessed November 2026. Source ↗
- AFIA DDGS Analytical Methods Sub-Working Group (2007). Evaluation of analytical methods for analysis of dried distillers grains with solubles: final report and recommendations. February 2007, hosted by AAFCO. Source ↗
- Brociek RA, Li D, Broughton R, Gardner DS (2025). Nutritional analysis of commercially available, complete plant- and meat-based dry dog foods in the UK. PLOS ONE 20(9):e0328506. Source ↗
- Herrman T (2001). Evaluating feed components and finished feeds. MF-2037. Kansas State University Agricultural Experiment Station and Cooperative Extension Service (Table 3 reproduces the AAFCO Official Publication 2000 analytical variations). Source ↗
- Association of American Feed Control Officials. Calorie content. AAFCO startup resources (web page), accessed November 2026. Source ↗
- Fischer K. AAFCO AV limits in consideration of current AAFCO PT results. Office of the Texas State Chemist, presentation hosted by AAFCO (undated). Source ↗
- University of Kentucky Division of Regulatory Services. Feed: sample tolerances (12 KAR 2:021, updated 2018). Web page, accessed November 2026. Source ↗
- California Department of Food and Agriculture, Commercial Feed Regulatory Program. Commercial feed label guarantees guidance. CDFA (undated). Source ↗
- Fan Y, Liao J, Zhou Q, Liu Y, Che L, Tang J (2024). Rapid prediction of the chemical composition of pet food using a benchtop and handheld near-infrared spectrometer. Spectrochimica Acta Part A: Molecular and Biomolecular Spectroscopy 323:124916. Source ↗
- Association of American Feed Control Officials (2023). Pet and specialty pet Nutrition Facts: major label changes. Pet Food Label Modernization resource, July 2023. Source ↗
Evidence reviewed by the Guires Pet Nutrition Lab scientific team. This article is general information for product developers and is not legal or veterinary advice.
How to cite this article
Choose your referencing style, then copy. Check your university’s, journal’s or regulator’s guide for local variations.
Mehta, P. (2026, November 13). Proximate analysis of pet food: methods, tolerances and turnaround. Guires Pet Nutrition Lab Insights. https://www.petnutritionlab.com/insights/proximate-analysis-pet-food
Mehta, Priya. “Proximate analysis of pet food: methods, tolerances and turnaround.” Guires Pet Nutrition Lab Insights, 13 Nov. 2026, www.petnutritionlab.com/insights/proximate-analysis-pet-food. Accessed [date].
Mehta, P. (2026) Proximate analysis of pet food: methods, tolerances and turnaround. Available at: https://www.petnutritionlab.com/insights/proximate-analysis-pet-food (Accessed: [date accessed]).
Mehta, Priya. “Proximate analysis of pet food: methods, tolerances and turnaround.” Guires Pet Nutrition Lab Insights. November 13, 2026. https://www.petnutritionlab.com/insights/proximate-analysis-pet-food.
Priya Mehta, ‘Proximate analysis of pet food: methods, tolerances and turnaround’, Guires Pet Nutrition Lab Insights, 13 November 2026, <https://www.petnutritionlab.com/insights/proximate-analysis-pet-food>, accessed [date accessed].
Mehta P. Proximate analysis of pet food: methods, tolerances and turnaround [Internet]. Guires Pet Nutrition Lab Insights; 2026 Nov 13 [cited [date]]. Available from: https://www.petnutritionlab.com/insights/proximate-analysis-pet-food
P. Mehta, “Proximate analysis of pet food: methods, tolerances and turnaround,” Guires Pet Nutrition Lab Insights, Nov. 13, 2026. [Online]. Available: https://www.petnutritionlab.com/insights/proximate-analysis-pet-food
@misc{guirespnl2026proximateanalysispetfood,
author = {Mehta, Priya},
title = {{Proximate analysis of pet food: methods, tolerances and turnaround}},
year = {2026},
month = oct,
howpublished = {\url{https://www.petnutritionlab.com/insights/proximate-analysis-pet-food}},
note = {Guires Pet Nutrition Lab Insights}
}
This article summarises published evidence for product developers. Cite the original sources above for specific findings, and do not reproduce this article as your own work.
Commissioning a proximate panel?
Tell us the product and the claims. We scope the methods, sample plan and reporting basis so the results stand up.