Guaranteed analysis explained: what each line means and how it is tested

The panel on the back of the bag looks like a measurement, but each line is a limit with a direction. Here is what each one promises, how a lab tests it and how brands should set it.

PM
By Priya MehtaGuires PNL scientific team
Reviewed byGuires PNL nutrition science and regulatory teams
Published13 Nov 2026
Last checked13 Nov 2026
Reading time7 minutes
Key takeaways
  • AAFCO model regulations require four guarantees on US dog and cat food: minimum crude protein and crude fat, and maximum crude fibre and moisture.
  • An official sample must not fall below a minimum or above a maximum, so each figure is a limit rather than the exact content.
  • In FDA’s worked example the dry food has the highest protein as fed (37%) but the lowest on a dry matter basis (42%, against 54.5% and 50% for two canned foods).
  • AAFCO advises setting guarantees from at least two analyses per variety; in its four-batch example a 24.8% protein mean supported only a 22% minimum.
Dog and cat beside a bowl of kibble, a checklist clipboard and laboratory glassware used for nutrient testing
EvidenceModerateWhy: AAFCO and FDA guidance agree, but the label format is changing under PFLM and state adoption varies. Rated by the Guires Pet Nutrition Lab scientific team
JurisdictionUS: AAFCO model regulations adopted by states
Required linesProtein and fat (min); fibre and moisture (max)
Use it forReading labels fairly and setting guarantees from batch data
Quick answer

Guaranteed analysis is the nutrient panel on a US dog or cat food label. It must state minimum crude protein and crude fat and maximum crude fibre and moisture 1. Each figure is a limit that an official sample must not fall short of or exceed, not the exact content, and brands should set it from laboratory results across several batches 2. To compare a wet food with a dry one, convert each figure to a dry matter basis first 3.

01What the panel is, and who requires it

The panel looks like a measurement, but it is a promise with a direction. This guide covers what each line promises, how it is tested, and what it cannot tell you.

In the US, the requirement comes from the AAFCO Model Pet Food Regulations. These are not federal law, but most states have adopted a version of them 1. The federal rules in 21 CFR part 501 cover items such as product identity, net quantity, the manufacturer’s name and address, and the ingredient list, and they do not mention guaranteed analysis 4. Each state where you sell can add its own rules 4.

Beyond the four required lines, other guarantees are voluntary. The exception is a claim: a pack that says “with calcium” needs a calcium guarantee 2. Ash is optional, but if it is listed it must be a maximum placed straight after moisture 1. Calories are not part of the panel. They sit in a separate “Calorie Content” statement, in kcal per kg as fed and per familiar unit such as a cup or can 1; our guide to calculating metabolisable energy explains how that figure is derived.

02Line by line: what each figure promises

“Crude” names the analytical method, not the quality of the nutrient 1. If a feed control official samples the product, protein and fat must be no lower than the label and fibre and moisture no higher 2.

LineDirectionTypical reference methodWhat to know
Crude proteinMinimumNitrogen by combustion (AOAC 990.03) or Kjeldahl, × 6.25 5Can overestimate protein from vegetable sources 6
Crude fatMinimumAcid hydrolysis (e.g. AOAC 954.02) for dry, extruded and semi-moist pet food 7AAFCO’s lab guidance says the method should always be reported 7
Crude fibreMaximumAcid then alkali digestion (AOAC 978.10) 8The digestions remove part of the structural carbohydrate and lignin, so the result understates total fibre 8
MoistureMaximumLoss on dryingAlways required; dilutes every other as-fed figure 2
Ash (optional)Maximum, if listedResidue after burningListed straight after moisture 1

Table 1. The required lines and how they are tested. Method numbers are common reference methods, not the only accepted ones.

The fibre gap matters enough to have its own guide: crude fibre vs dietary fibre.

03As fed vs dry matter basis

The panel is written as fed, with water included. AAFCO nutrient profiles are written on dry matter, so a label must be converted before it is checked against a profile. FDA’s method: dry matter is 100 minus the moisture guarantee, and the dry matter value is the guarantee divided by percent dry matter, times 100 3.

The gap is large because canned food is typically 75–78% moisture and dry food 10–12% 3. In FDA’s adult cat example, the dry food has by far the highest protein figure on the label but the lowest on a dry matter basis. All three foods clear the 26% dry matter minimum for adult cat maintenance 3. For more worked examples, see dry matter basis.

Figure 1The dry food ranks first as fed and last on dry matterMinimum crude protein, %
Canned 1, as fed
12
Canned 1, dry matter
54.5
Canned 2, as fed
11
Canned 2, dry matter
50
Dry, as fed
37
Dry, dry matter
42

Label guarantees from FDA’s worked example (canned foods 78% moisture, dry food 12%) and their calculated dry matter values 3. Illustrative labels, not measured products. Axis 0–60%.

View data table
FoodProtein as fed (%)Moisture (%)Protein, dry matter (%)
Canned food 1127854.5
Canned food 2117850
Dry food371242

04Setting guarantees from batch data

AAFCO advises laboratory analysis unless a brand formulates with software and a complete, accurate nutrient database. A proximate analysis of the finished product covers crude protein, fat, fibre, moisture and ash, and results are usually reported as fed, so confirm the basis with the lab 2. One analysis is not enough: start with at least two per variety and add more as batches are made 2.

AAFCO’s four-batch example shows why. Protein ran from 23% to 26%. Batch one alone (25%) would have suggested a guarantee that batch four missed. The mean minus two standard deviations gave 22.25%, so the recommended minimum was 22% 2. The simpler rule is to take the lowest protein or fat result and round down, and the highest fibre or moisture result and round up 2.

Figure 2Four batches, one guaranteeCrude protein, % as fed
Batch 1
25
Batch 2
26
Batch 3
25.2
Batch 4
23
Mean
24.8
Guarantee (min)
22

AAFCO’s worked example for a pet treat; measured batch results and the recommended label minimum 2. Axis 0–30%.

View data table
BatchCrude protein (% as fed)
125
226
325.2
423
Mean24.8
Recommended minimum22

In 70 cat and 36 dog foods, near-infrared (NIR) models predicted crude protein, fat and moisture well, but crude fibre and ash poorly and calcium and phosphorus very poorly 9.

05What the panel does not show

  • Exact content. In 18 insect-based dog foods sold in South Korea, label and laboratory values differed in 7 10. In 31 UK dry dog foods, measured protein corresponded well with the label 6.
  • Micronutrients. In the same UK study, 17 of 31 foods (55%) met the essential amino acid minimums and only 5 (16%) met all FEDIAF mineral guidelines 6.
  • Digestibility. In 24 beagles, replacing maize with 3, 6 or 12% guava fibre lowered the digestibility of dry matter, protein and energy 11. A fibre maximum says nothing about this.
  • Life stage. The nutritional adequacy statement, not the panel, says whether the food is complete and balanced and for which life stage 1.

Before you compare two labels

  • Check the adequacy statement and life stage first.
  • Convert protein and fat to dry matter when moisture differs.
  • Compare energy from the calorie statement, not from protein or fat.
  • Read minimums and maximums as limits, not as content.

06What changes under label modernization

AAFCO’s Pet Food Label Modernization (PFLM) replaces the panel with a Pet Nutrition Facts box. In AAFCO’s example, the box lists protein and fat without the word “crude”, swaps crude fibre for dietary fibre, and adds a calculated total carbohydrate maximum 12. AAFCO reports that PFLM is being implemented state by state 13, so check which format each state you sell into accepts. Our guide to AAFCO label modernization covers the timeline.

Guaranteed analysis today

  • Crude protein (min)
  • Crude fat (min)
  • Crude fibre (max)
  • Moisture (max)
  • Calories in a separate statement

Pet Nutrition Facts box

  • Protein (min)
  • Fat (min)
  • Total carbohydrate (max, calculated)
  • Dietary fibre (max)
  • Moisture (max), with calories in the box

Based on AAFCO’s PFLM example box 12.

Guires Pet Nutrition Lab verdict

The guaranteed analysis is a floor and a ceiling, not a certificate of content. Read each line by its direction, convert to dry matter before comparing formats, and set guarantees from more than one batch. Plan the dietary fibre and carbohydrate data PFLM will need now.

07For brands and formulators

08Questions brands ask

What does guaranteed analysis mean on pet food?

It is the required nutrient panel on a US pet food label: minimum crude protein and crude fat, and maximum crude fibre and moisture. Each figure is a limit an official sample must meet, not the exact content of the bag.

Is guaranteed analysis the actual nutrient content?

No. It is a minimum or maximum. In one study of 18 insect-based dog foods, label and laboratory values differed in 7, so only analysis of your own batches shows the real content.

Why convert guaranteed analysis to dry matter?

The panel is written as fed, while AAFCO nutrient profiles are on dry matter. Converting removes the dilution from water, which is why a canned food with 12% protein as fed can hold more protein per unit of dry matter than a kibble with 37%.

How many lab analyses do you need to set a guarantee?

AAFCO advises at least two analyses per variety to start, adding more as batches are produced. Set the minimum below the low end of the spread, not from the best batch.

Is the guaranteed analysis being replaced?

Under AAFCO’s Pet Food Label Modernization, a Pet Nutrition Facts box replaces it, using dietary fibre instead of crude fibre and adding total carbohydrate. States adopt the change on their own schedules.

Label verification cluster · Part 1 of 7

Read the label verification guides in order

  1. Guaranteed analysis explained · you are here
  2. Crude fibre vs dietary fibre · why the label figure reads low
  3. How accurate are pet food labels? · one label vs lab study explained
  4. Calories in dog food · label vs measured energy, graded
  5. Proximate analysis of pet food · methods, tolerances and turnaround
  6. Worked case study · a dog treat label checked across four batches
  7. Nutritional analysis · how we run it for your product

Sources

  1. Association of American Feed Control Officials. Reading labels: how to understand a dog or cat food label. AAFCO, web page, accessed November 2026. Source ↗
  2. Association of American Feed Control Officials. Nutritional labeling: how do I calculate the guaranteed analysis in my pet treats? AAFCO, web page, accessed November 2026. Source ↗
  3. US Food and Drug Administration (2020). “Complete and balanced” pet food. FDA Animal Health Literacy, content current as of 28 February 2020. Source ↗
  4. US Food and Drug Administration (2026). Animal food labeling and pet food claims. FDA, content current as of 2 March 2026. Source ↗
  5. UC Davis Analytical Laboratory. Total crude protein in feed materials: combustion method (AOAC Official Method 990.03). Method page, accessed November 2026. Source ↗
  6. Brociek RA, Li D, Broughton R, Gardner DS (2025). Nutritional analysis of commercially available, complete plant- and meat-based dry dog foods in the UK. PLOS ONE 20(9):e0328506. Source ↗
  7. AAFCO Laboratory Methods and Services Committee, Fat Best Practices Working Group (2014). Crude fat best practices guidelines. AAFCO. Source ↗
  8. UC Davis Analytical Laboratory. Crude fiber (AOAC Official Method 978.10, Fiber (Crude) in Animal Feed and Pet Food). Method page, accessed November 2026. Source ↗
  9. Fan Y, Liao J, Zhou Q, Liu Y, Che L, Tang J (2024). Rapid prediction of the chemical composition of pet food using a benchtop and handheld near-infrared spectrometer. Spectrochimica Acta Part A: Molecular and Biomolecular Spectroscopy 323:124916. Source ↗
  10. Ryu MO, Lee KH, Ha HM, Kim HR, Ahn WS, Kim SH, Seo KW (2025). Proximate analysis and profiles of amino acids, fatty acids, and minerals in insect-based foods for dogs. American Journal of Veterinary Research 86(1):ajvr.24.08.0243. Source ↗
  11. Monti M, Loureiro BA, Pedreira RS, Mendonça FS, Putarov TC, Villaverde C, Carciofi AC (2024). Guava fibre characterization and effects on digestibility, fermentation products, gastrointestinal transit time and palatability of dry diets for dogs. Journal of Animal Physiology and Animal Nutrition 108(2):500–510. Source ↗
  12. Association of American Feed Control Officials (2023). Pet Food Label Modernization: Pet Nutrition Facts example, version 07-31-2023. AAFCO. Source ↗
  13. Association of American Feed Control Officials (2026). AAFCO quarterly newsletter, Q1 2026. AAFCO. Source ↗

Evidence reviewed by the Guires Pet Nutrition Lab scientific team. This article is general information for product developers and is not legal or veterinary advice.

How to cite this article

Choose your referencing style, then copy. Check your university’s, journal’s or regulator’s guide for local variations.

Mehta, P. (2026, November 13). Guaranteed analysis explained: what each line means and how it is tested. Guires Pet Nutrition Lab Insights. https://www.petnutritionlab.com/insights/guaranteed-analysis-explained

This article summarises published evidence for product developers. Cite the original sources above for specific findings, and do not reproduce this article as your own work.

Setting the guarantees for a new label?

Send us your recipe and batch results. We set guarantees from batch data and check every line against AAFCO rules before print.

FEDIAFAAFCO

Every Guires PNL product is formulated to comply with the FEDIAF Nutritional Guidelines and the AAFCO Dog and Cat Food Nutrient Profiles. Neither body issues certificates to manufacturers, so compliance is verified independently against their published standards — and every product comes with a complete documentation package for regulatory submissions in the EU, US, Australia and Asian markets.

How we verify compliance →
Request a quote Call us WhatsApp Email us